SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: FOO FIGHTERS – YOUR FAVORITE TOY

FOO FIGHTERS
YOUR FAVORITE TOY
RCA RECORDS

Foo Fighters have returned with their 12th studio album, Your Favorite Toy. The album is their first release since 2023’s But Here We Are and marks the debut of drummer Ilan Rubin. The record comes ahead of their 2026 stadium tour with Queens Of The Stone Age and follows a tumultuous period for the band, serving as something of a comeback from a band that spent the better part of the last two decades as a seemingly unstoppable force in modern rock.

“Caught In The Echo” opens the album with an offbeat riff and Dave Grohl’s throaty screams. There is an air of triumph as an uplifting chorus sweeps in following a polyrhythmic verse that packs a nasty bite. “Caught in the Echo” is a challenging song, one that highlights the musicianship in the band and sets the momentum for the most recent single, “Of All People” to follow. This is a scathing track driven by lyrical themes of survivor’s guilt and reflecting on those who have passed and those still with us. “Of All People” revels with a hard-hitting bombast and is the heaviest songs on the record. Together, “Caught In The Echo” and “Of All People” serve as a strong opening pair and as two of the strongest tracks on Your Favorite Toy.

As Foo Fighters continue through the remaining eight tracks, they struggle to capture the same highs established in the two openers. Sure, the winding riff of “Window” is very ‘90s and “If You Only Knew” is led by one of the strongest choruses on the album, but most of Your Favorite Toy suffers from being good, but rather unremarkable. Despite this, Foo Fighters have made a solid effort to carve a distinct path from their body of work on their latest album. In addition to the opening songs, highlights include “Spite Shine” and the lead single, “Asking for a Friend.” Where the former delivers one of the best riffs from the band in years, the latter stands as a benchmark in songwriting, performance, and intensity. “Asking for a Friend” opens with a reflective arpeggio of fuzzy guitars before erupting into an absolute anthem of a pre-chorus, that is further elevated by the addition of the chorus itself. Brief instrumental passages serve to only heighten the intensity as the song grows into an overwhelming wave of distortion, reaching a point of climax as a ripper of a riff comes out of nowhere as a means of transitioning into a guitar solo. “Asking for a Friend” is incredibly heavy and, from a songwriting perspective, is driven by a progressive rock influence, showcasing the very best elements the band has to offer. Ultimately, “Asking for a Friend” can go toe to toe with some of the best songs from Foo Fighters.

With their upcoming Take Cover Tour announced last October, with only the lead single, “Asking for a Friend,” released without any word of an upcoming album, a number of European and North American dates are already sold out, with limited tickets available for the remaining dates. It is clear that Foo Fighters do not need a current radio hit to embark on a massive stadium tour. Here lies my ongoing frustrations with the band. Over the years, Grohl and company have flexed rare moments that demonstrate a far heavier nature (“White Limo,” “Run”), a willingness to embrace more alternative tones (“Shame Shame”), or a willingness to write progressive material (“The Teacher”). Despite this, Your Favorite Toy, for all its feats, is a very safe album that flexes these elements briefly, but returns to a comfortable, middle of the road position. I long for the day where Foo Fighters truly indulge in their heaviest, most alternative, and ambitiously progressive songs. Still, Your Favorite Toy is a good record, one that establishes a new direction for the band and their new line up.

Artist Links