The Spill Magazine The Spill Magazine
The Spill Magazine The Spill Magazine
The Spill Magazine The Spill Magazine
  • Reviews
    • Album Reviews
    • Features
    • Live Reviews
    • Festivals
  • Headlines
    • News
    • ILLUSTRATIONS
    • Contests
    • Events
    • Entertainment Headlines
    • Concert Listings
    • Toronto Concert Venues
    • Portraits
  • New Music
    • Premieres
    • Track Of The Day
  • Track Of The Month
  • Books + Movies
  • About
16
new
SPILL NEW MUSIC: BRIT DROZDA – “GO AS A RIVER”
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: VARIOUS ARTISTS – PURPLE STORM: A TRIBUTE TO DEEP PURPLE
SPILL FEATURE: IT GIVES ME PURPOSE AND I LOVE IT – A CONVERSATION WITH KIM MITCHELL
SPILL NEW MUSIC: GOO GOO DOLLS NEW, LIMITED EDITION ‘DIZZY UP THE GIRL’ BUFFALO, NY CITY VINYL
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: THE DESCENDENTS – BONUS FAT
SPILL NEWS: AUSTRA RELEASES TWO NEW B-SIDES + ANNOUNCES CANADIAN TOUR DATES
SPILL NEWS: DEATH FROM ABOVE 1979 SHARE ‘PRIVATE LIVES (STEVE AOKI 3LKTR0 REMIX) + MINI DOCUMENTARY | TOUR DATES
SPILL NEW MUSIC: TURNING JANE’S ‘QUEEN OF HEARTS’ BRINGS ATTITUDE, TEMPTATION, HEARTBREAK AND UNAPOLOGETIC CONFIDENCE TOGETHER
SPILL NEW MUSIC: MURRAY McLAUCHLAN RECLAIMS HIS CLASSICS ON ‘RECOVERED’ WITH NEW RECORDINGS OF “DOWN BY THE HENRY MOORE”, “THE FARMER’S SONG” AND “CHILD’S SONG”
SPILL NEW MUSIC: STEREOPHONICS ANNOUNCE ‘TUNE! ULTIMATE COLLECTION 96-26’
SPILL NEWS: DAN MANGAN REVEALS NEW SINGLE “I HAVE WON THE WAR ALREADY” | ANNOUNCES APRIL 2027 SOLO PERFORMANCES
SPILL NEWS: ALEXISONFIRE RELEASE NEW SINGLE “PUSH THE RIVER” | ANNOUNCE NEW ALBUM ‘BLEED IT’ OUT MARCH 19
SPILL NEW MUSIC: THEO MOSS – “SPINNING”
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: JAH WOBBLE & THE INVADERS OF THE HEART – THE USUAL SUSPECTS
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: JOE GLASS – SNAKEWARDS
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: ZEBRA – ZEBRA V
  • Reviews
    • Album Reviews
    • Features
    • Live Reviews
    • Festivals
  • Headlines
    • News
    • ILLUSTRATIONS
    • Contests
    • Events
    • Entertainment Headlines
    • Concert Listings
    • Toronto Concert Venues
    • Portraits
  • New Music
    • Premieres
    • Track Of The Day
  • Track Of The Month
  • Books + Movies
  • About
  • Spill Menu
    • Reviews
      • Album Reviews
      • Features
      • Live Reviews
      • Festivals
    • Headlines
      • News
      • ILLUSTRATIONS
      • Contests
      • Events
      • Entertainment Headlines
      • Concert Listings
      • Toronto Concert Venues
      • Portraits
    • New Music
      • Premieres
      • Track Of The Day
    • Track Of The Month
    • Books + Movies
    • About
Album Reviews
1
4285
Editor Pick
previous article
SPILL EXCLUSIVE MIX PREMIERE: NIGHT DRIVE - (SPECIAL MIX) + NEW SINGLE "TRAPEZE ARTIST REGRETS"
next article
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: HEADSTONES - LITTLE ARMY

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: ROGER WATERS – IS THIS THE LIFE WE REALLY WANT?

Roger Waters

Roger Waters
Is This The Life We Really Want?
Sony Music

Roger Waters, one of the most consistently strong songwriters to emerge from the booming 1960s British invasion rock scene, has returned with Is This The Life We Really Want?, his first album since 2005’s Ça Ira.  A lot has changed in the world, both musically and politically, in the twelve years in which the Pink Floyd founder and one of rock’s most outspoken and prolific front-men has been absent from the business of record making. In some ways, with the odd exception, rock music has become rather passive in regards to political and social issues. Similarly, most musicians who got their start around the same period as Waters, again with the odd exception, have stopped releasing new music, or continue to release the rare album here and there, each running on nostalgic fumes in an attempt to leave their audience digging through their back catalogue, rather than attempting to be innovative. Is This The Life We Really Want? is the exception to both of these sadly common trends, proving once again, that Roger Waters’ creative mind is just as sharp as his razor tongue.

Is This The Life We Really Want? opens with a muffled voice over, along with a ticking clock and a steady heartbeat, until Waters breaks through the mud in what can be described as a biting and bitter introduction, which begs the listener to open his or her heart and search for the hard truths as to where we personally and socially are now. In tone, Waters sounds like he is voicing over a trailer for a major film in which he is the sole survivor, willing to lift his guitar high in the air for the sake of justice. He sounds angry, determined, and confident in the fact that he very well may be one of the last classic rockers who is willing to write such a timely and prolific album to address the world in 2017. This introduction, “When We Were Young”, leads seamlessly into the musical equivalent that is “Déjà Vu”, a song brimming with frustration, reminiscing, and sorrow, and Waters’ voice perfectly captures the vulnerability, and at times fear, that is felt across the globe in such uncertain times.

The music across Is This The Life We Really Want? is very simple, and often minimalistic.  Like much of Waters’ career, in and out of Pink Floyd, nothing is all that complicated, and this is where the music shines most. Waters is a master at writing simple songs that communicate, and at times even demand, a deep emotional connection or response from the music. Is This The Life We Really Want? is no different that that. “Picture That”, one of the album’s most standout tracks, is a testament to the fact that Waters tackles such controversial issues as the likes of the social consequences of conflict in the Middle East, American gun violence, greed and corruption among politicians and the upper elite, and “the leader with no fucken brains”, Donald Trump. The song, like anything Waters sings across the record, commands your attention and leaves you hanging on his words, anxiously awaiting what will come next from his smooth yet gravelly voice. While minimal, the effects used in post-production are reminiscent of Waters’ work with Pink Floyd, and there is a certain jazz sensibility to the album that sparks a feeling of improvisation, tension and release. It is this element that links Is This The Life We Really Want? to David Bowie’s swansong, Blackstar, and is best heard on the record’s title track, “Is This The Life We Really Want?”, “The Most Beautiful Girl In The World”, and the classically charged groove of “Smell The Roses” — a track which truly taps the Pink Floyd vein for a tastefully retro energy.

Through my numerous play-throughs of the album, there was nothing that I would want differently. To put it bluntly, Roger Waters is a genius and Is This The Life We Really Want? can stand among some of his best work.  From the beautiful acoustic ballad, “Part Of Me Died”, to the thrilling title track, which feels like a sleek soundtrack for an espionage movie and stands out for its brilliant minimalism and inspiration from Bowie’s “Blackstar”, Waters remains one of the most prolific artists by delivering one of the sonically best albums of the year, and what may be among the most socially important albums of the decade, along with Kendrick Lamar’s To Pimp A Butterfly.  Is This The Life We Really Want ?is a flawless modern masterpiece that will be revered as a shaper of music to come, and as a perfect demonstration as to how artistry and protest can come together in a seamless fashion in which they play off of each other to create a bigger and better statement than either could never make on their own.



Artist Links

website_flat_2016 facebook_flat_2016 twitter_flat_2016

Editor Pick
Item Reviewed

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: ROGER WATERS – IS THIS THE LIFE WE REALLY WANT?

Author

Gerrod Harris

Here's what we think...
Spill Rating
Fan Rating
Rate Here
New Criteria
10
27.2
10
Total Spill Rating
27.2
Total Fan Rating
50 ratings
You have rated this
Album Reviews
album reviewsis this the life we really want?pink floydroger waterssmell the rosessony music
album reviews, is this the life we really want?, pink floyd, roger waters, smell the roses, sony music
About the Author
Gerrod Harris
Gerrod Harris is a Toronto based musician, writer, and podcast host. Since 2017, he has actively contributed to The Spill Magazine through coverage focused on a wide array of artists and genres alike. In addition to his writing, Harris hosts the podcast, Beats by Ger, where he delves into various aspects of music, sharing insights and engaging relevant discussions. As the drummer and manager of independent rock band, One in the Chamber, his passion for music goes beyond the pen as an active member of Toronto's vibrant musical community.
RELATED ARTICLES
album reviewsis this the life we really want?pink floyd
 
8.0
Deep Purple

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: VARIOUS ARTISTS – PURPLE STORM: A TRIBUTE TO DEEP PURPLE

by Aaron Badgley on November 13, 2026
VARIOUS ARTISTS PURPLE STORM: A TRIBUTE TO DEEP PURPLE CLEOPATRA RECORDS Purple Storm—A Tribute To Deep Purple is not the first tribute album to Deep Purple, but it is a very interesting one. Members of various bands have come together to pay [...]
 
7.0
The Descendents

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: THE DESCENDENTS – BONUS FAT

by John Porter on November 13, 2026
THE DESCENDENTS BONUS FAT ORG MUSIC Bonus Fat is an amusing and fun collection of some of the first recordings of the Descendents’ career, marking a point in time where things got faster and more hardcore, to quote frontman Milo Aukerman during [...]
 
8.0
Jah Wobble

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: JAH WOBBLE & THE INVADERS OF THE HEART – THE USUAL SUSPECTS

by Bryan Williston on November 13, 2026
JAH WOBBLE & THE INVADERS OF THE HEART THE USUAL SUSPECTS DIMPLE DISCS Dimple Discs is celebrating the reissue of The Usual Suspects, by Jah Wobble & the Invaders of the Heart. This is an expansive project driven by Wobble, the post-punk [...]
 
8.0
Joe Glass

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: JOE GLASS – SNAKEWARDS

by Aaron Badgley on November 13, 2026
JOE GLASS SNAKEWARDS K RECORDS/PERENNIAL RECORDS Armed with just a Telecaster, Joe Glass is on a mission to keep rock ‘n’ roll alive, and he succeeds. Based in Chicago, Glass has been firmly established as a touring musician. With Snakewards, [...]
 
8.0
Zebra
10

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: ZEBRA – ZEBRA V

by Aaron Badgley on November 13, 2026
ZEBRA ZEBRA V FLATIRON RECORDINGS Like U2, Zebra has been a band, with the original members, for a very long time. Since 1975 to be exact. Unlike U2, it has been 23 years since Zebra released a studio album. Since 2003’s Zebra IV, the band has [...]
Latest Album Reviews
View All
 
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: VARIOUS ARTISTS – PURPLE STORM: A TRIBUTE...
8.0
 
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: THE DESCENDENTS – BONUS FAT
7.0
 
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: JAH WOBBLE & THE INVADERS OF THE HEART ...
8.0
 
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: JOE GLASS – SNAKEWARDS
8.0
 
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: ZEBRA – ZEBRA V
8.0
10

STAY UP-TO-DATE
WITH OUR WEEKLY NEWSLETTER!

New Music
View All
 
Brit Drozda

SPILL NEW MUSIC: BRIT DROZDA – “GO AS A RIVER”

 
Goo Goo Dolls

SPILL NEW MUSIC: GOO GOO DOLLS NEW, LIMITED EDITION ‘DIZZY UP THE GIRL’ BUFFALO, NY CITY VINYL

 
Turning Jane

SPILL NEW MUSIC: TURNING JANE’S ‘QUEEN OF HEARTS’ BRINGS ATTITUDE, TEMPTATION, HEARTBREAK AND UNAPOLOGETIC CONFIDENCE TOGETHER

 
Murray McLauchlan

SPILL NEW MUSIC: MURRAY McLAUCHLAN RECLAIMS HIS CLASSICS ON ‘RECOVERED’ WITH NEW RECORDINGS OF “DOWN BY THE HENRY MOORE”, “THE FARMER’S SONG” AND “CH...

 
Stereophonics

SPILL NEW MUSIC: STEREOPHONICS ANNOUNCE ‘TUNE! ULTIMATE COLLECTION 96-26’

 
Theo Moss

SPILL NEW MUSIC: THEO MOSS – “SPINNING”

 
Dismantlists

SPILL MUSIC PREMIERE: DISMANTLISTS – “WHEN YOU RUN AWAY BUT CAN STILL SEE THE HOUSE”

SPILL MAGAZINE MENU
  • Home | The Spill Magazine
  • ILLUSTRATIONS
  • Newsletter
  • Premieres
  • Track Of The Month
  • Album Reviews
  • Books + Movies
  • Features
  • Live Reviews
  • Festivals
  • Portraits
  • News
  • Events
  • Entertainment Headlines
  • Concert Listings
  • Toronto Concert Venues
  • About Us
  • Contests
  • New Music
  • Contributors
  • TOTD
  • Privacy Policy
  • The Scene Unseen
  • Newsletter

Copyright © 2026 | The Spill Magazine
All Rights Reserved.

TRENDING RIGHT NOW
   
 
SPILL TRACK OF THE MONTH: BLACK DOLDRUMS – “COMPULSION”
2444
 
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: ROGER TAYLOR – VIOLENCE INSANE IN A BEAUTIFUL WORLD
1540
 
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: THE WARNING – EVERYTHING’S FALLING
1320
 
SPILL NEWS: TRICKY’S NORTH AMERICAN TOUR BEGINS THIS FRIDAY SEPTEMBER 18 | NEW ALBUM ‘DIFFERENT WHEN IT’S SILENT’ OUT VIA FALSE IDOLS
1139
 
SPILL NEWS: DREW RYDER SMITH TEAMS WITH STEVE EARLE FOR NEW SINGLE AND VIDEO “TEXTILE TOWN” | MUSIC VIDEO FILMED IN FORMER TEXTILE MILLS BRINGS TO LIFE A DEEPLY PERSONAL SONG INSPIRED BY SOUTHERN M...
1052
 
SPILL NEW MUSIC: MEL DENISSE – “HUNTED”
977
 
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: U2 – CARNAVAL DE LUZ
910
 
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: SOFT CELL – DANCETERIA
788
 
SPILL MUSIC PREMIERE: COR DE LUX – “BLIND SMILE”
748
 
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: ZEBRA – ZEBRA V
721
 
SPILL NEW MUSIC: ERIC SCHENKMAN – “HIT ON ME”
698
 
SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: THE AFGHAN WHIGS – SOFT CONTROL
651
 
SPILL LIVE REVIEW: TURNSTILE @ WOODBINE PARK, TORONTO
650
ENTERTAINMENT HEADLINES