SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: GREAT LAKE SWIMMERS - THEY DON'T MAKE THEM LIKE THAT ANYMORE

Great Lake Swimmers
They Don’t Make Them Like That Anymore
Nettwerk

Great Lake Swimmers return after 2016’s EP Swimming Away, with the ever appropriately titled EP, They Don’t Make Them Like That Anymore. This one is a four track Christmas themed EP featuring two new songs and two traditional Christmas songs. They Don’t Make Them Like That Anymore is an beautiful set and I sincerely wish they had made an album instead of just an EP. It is also the perfect title for this EP.

The title track “They Don’t Make Them Like That Anymore” is one of the most melancholic Christmas songs since Judy Garland sang the original lyrics of “Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas”. Julie Doiron adds haunting harmonies that further adds to the beauty of this track. For those who have loved ones not with them at Christmas, this song is custom made for you. This song focuses on those missing, rather than those gathered around the table. Heartbreaking.

The mood does not lighten with the second original song, “Ink For A Star”. More of a musical and lyrical collage of all that comes to mind when thinking of Christmas, but again, it is the nostalgic feeling and the sense of loss that haunts this song. It is a stunning song, beautifully played, just very melancholic.

Great Lake Swimmers round out the set with two very traditional Christmas carols. “It Came Upon A Midnight Clear” (dating from 1849) and the seldom heard, but much loved, “Bring A Torch, Jeannette, Isabel” (dating from the 17th Century). These are traditional versions, acoustic and quite simply sublime.

Suffice to say, this is an EP that would not be ideal for the annual Christmas party. We see it as more for those moments of silent reflection after a busy day of preparing for Christmas. They Don’t Make Them Like That Anymore is a reminder of the meaning of the holidays and as a a reminder for all of us in Charles Dickens’ words, that Christmas is “a kind, forgiving, charitable time.”

Artist Links

Editor Pick

Item Reviewed

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: GREAT LAKE SWIMMERS – THEY DON’T MAKE THEM LIKE THAT ANYMORE

Author

Aaron Badgley

Here's what we think...

Spill Rating

Fan Rating

Rate Here

New Criteria

9.0

Total Spill Rating

9.0

Total Fan Rating

1 rating

You have rated this

album reviews great lake swimmers it came upon a midnight clear nettwerk they don't make them like that anymore

album reviews, great lake swimmers, it came upon a midnight clear, nettwerk, they don't make them like that anymore

About the Author

Aaron Badgley

Born and raised in Whitby, Aaron discovered music through his love of The Beatles. This led to a career in radio, writing for various publications, and ultimately a radio show about The Beatles (Beatles Universe), which ran for over four years. When not immersed in music, Aaron enjoys spending time with the loves of his life -- his wife Andrea, and daughters Emily and Linda (all of whom have an intense love of music too).

album reviews great lake swimmers nettwerk

8.0

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: MAX SUBAR – ANYTHING COULD BE

by Ljubinko Zivkovic on July 17, 2026

MAX SUBAR ANYTHING COULD BE MERGE RECORDS If by looking at the cover for Max Subar’s album, Anything Could Be, you get the impression that you are looking at (and possibly will listen to) a typical singer-songwriter album, you would be [...]

8.0

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: CR & THE WHITE LIGHTS – MY OLD SELF

by Ljubinko Zivkovic on July 17, 2026

CR & THE WHITE LIGHTS MY OLD SELF MAGIC DOOR RECORDS If My Old Self would. be your first encounter with CR & The White Lights you could easily think that these guys are hiding somewhere in a Nashville suburb where alt Americana thrives [...]

8.0

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: LISA MOLINARO – BLIND TRUST

by Aaron Badgley on July 17, 2026

LISA MOLINARO BLIND TRUST INDEPENDENT Lisa Molinaro has had a fascinating career in music. Beyond her own writing and performing, she has been part of The National (their touring band), The Decemberists (their touring band), Modest Mouse, and [...]

7.0

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: THE AMPLIFIER HEADS – SUPER 8

by Aaron Badgley on July 17, 2026

THE AMPLIFIER HEADS SUPER 8 RUM BAR RECORDS Sal Baglio is part of rock and roll history. In 1977, he was a founding member of the classic Boston-based band The Stompers (who are in the New England Music Hall Of Fame) and although they never [...]

9.0

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: HOLY WAVE – I’M DADA

by Ljubinko Zivkovic on July 10, 2026

HOLY WAVE I’M DADA SUICIDE SQUEEZE RECORDS As time passes by, the critics have come up with so many genres and sub-genres in modern music seemingly to make it simpler for audiences to pick up their preferences. Yet, more and more, current [...]