SIMONE PUORTO – A CACTUS IN A DEAD LAND: PILGRIMAGE AND RITUAL IN THE CULTURAL AFTERLIFE OF IAN CURTIS AND JOY DIVISION (AND THE FORGOTTEN STORY OF CORNELIA F.)
INDEPENDENT
BOOK REVIEW BY AARON BADGLEY
A Cactus In A Dead Land: Pilgrimage And Ritual In The Cultural Afterlife Of Ian Curtis and Joy Division (And The Forgotten Story of Cornelia F.) is a very original and fascinating book. Few remember Joy Division prior to Curtis’s suicide, which firmly established several myths around the band. New Order has tried to break the mystic and just be ‘another band,’ but the ghost of Curtis has always haunted them. I remember buying Unknown Pleasures while Curtis was alive. It was a standout album, full of incredible, moving and original songs. But at the end of the day, it was just another album that was part of my collection. All that changed May 18, 1980 when Curtis ended his life. Joy Division was elevated to another level.
Puorto looks at that story and examines the notion of how Joy Division was perceived differently following his death. To be clear, this is not a biography or history about Joy Division, although their story and Curtis’s biography is included, but rather a book about their fans, perception and the afterlife. Not to mention the pilgrimage fans make to the burial site. According to Puorto, over 1000 people visit Curtis’s grave a year. Of course, Curtis is not alone in this with his fans, many artists who have passed away have a number of visitors (Jim Morrison’s grave is a prime example).
At the heart of this book, however, is the story of a German Joy Division fan, Cornelia F., who ended her life 13 years to the day of Curtis’s suicide and is, at her request, buried 17 graves away from Curtis’s memorial in the same cemetery. Puorto has researched Cornelia and includes her story, perhaps as the ultimate fan tribute to an artist. It is, however, very disturbing. It does give pause to think about the impact these artists have on their fans.
This is not an easy book to read, nor to put down. Puorto is an excellent writer and he has done a great deal of research, especially about Cornelia. Puorto is also very good and through his writing causes the reader to really think and look within. I visited my daughter in L.A. recently, and made a pilgrimage to a couple of cemeteries to see the stones of old actors whom I admire. Again, this book made me question my choices. And any book that can do that is an excellent text.
A Cactus In A Dead Land: Pilgrimage And Ritual In The Cultural Afterlife Of Ian Curtis and Joy Division (And The Forgotten Story of Cornelia F.) is original, well thought out, and a book that has taken a surprisingly long time to write. Puorto deserves a great deal of credit for writing this highly original work. He takes a very different look at the band and how fandom extends through generations and people’s lives.











