SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: MOTHER MOTHER - NOSTALGIA

MOTHER MOTHER
NOSTALGIA
WARNER RECORDS

Mother Mother’s new album Nostalgia delivers the retro spark fans have been craving. It’s everything we love about the band, with tracks that nod to their original sound while embracing bold, fresh ideas. At 36 minutes, the album is a tight, celebratory reflection of their 20-year journey.

Opener “Love to Death,” a long-anticipated track dating back to 2009, roots the record in the band’s personal history. “FINGER” plays like a modern sequel to “Verbatim”, revisiting its sharp social commentary with an unexpected and unforgettable intro. The lead single, “Make Believe,” is classic Mother Mother; upbeat, offbeat, and just the right amount of autotuned weirdness that longtime fans adore. The band’s creative freedom is on full display, pushing their sound and songwriting to new emotional and artistic heights. Nostalgia also highlights the full vocal range of the group, with several tracks giving the spotlight to members beyond lead singer Ryan Guldemond. Lyrically, the album is packed with emotionally charged moments, purposefully crafted to stir something deeper in the listener. It’s a confident, compelling evolution of their sound that is rooted in the past, but made for the now.

In the end, Nostalgia isn’t just a reflection on where Mother Mother has been, it’s a bold statement about where they’re going. It invites listeners to look back, feel deeply, and move forward with them, proving that after 20 years, the band still has plenty of surprises and soul left to share.

Artist Links

Item Reviewed

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: MOTHER MOTHER – NOSTALGIA

Author

Mercedes Chircop

Here's what we think...

Spill Rating

Fan Rating

Rate Here

New Criteria

—

8.0

Total Spill Rating

—

Total Fan Rating

You have rated this

album review album reviews finger mother mother nostalgia warner records

album review, album reviews, finger, mother mother, nostalgia, warner records

About the Author

Mercedes Chircop

Mercedes is a Toronto native with a huge passion for photography and creative writing. Her love of being behind the lens has given her the opportunity to capture captivating images for national campaigns and earned her publications in renowned international magazines. Beyond her photographic pursuits, Mercedes is an avid attendee of concerts, immersing herself in the live music experience and documenting it from the photo pit. While her musical tastes lean towards rock alternative, she also embarks on an indie rock journey, and on a day to day, she also indulges in coffee to an extent that rivals the Gilmore Girls, while her Italian heritage instilled a lifelong love for pasta, meatballs, and pizza (as long as it’s gluten-free and vegan).

album review album reviews mother mother

8.0

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: THE ROLLING STONES – FOREIGN TONGUES

by Gerrod Harris on July 10, 2026

THE ROLLING STONES FOREIGN TONGUES UNIVERSAL MUSIC The Rolling Stones are back. While 2023’s Hackney Diamonds may have given the impression of a fitting conclusion to perhaps one of pop culture’s greatest sagas, and despite questioning if they [...]

9.0

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: SUNDAYCLUB – SUNDAYCLUB

by John Porter on July 10, 2026

SUNDAYCLUB SUNDAYCLUB PAPER BAG RECORDS sundayclub has been riding something of a wave of momentum among those lucky enough to have heard about them since 2025’s Bannatyne, and with good reason; their combination of modern production, honest, [...]

8.0

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: SHE’S GREEN – SWALLOWTAIL

by Mercedes Chircop on July 10, 2026

SHE’S GREEN SWALLOWTAIL PHOTO FINISH RECORDS With Swallowtail, she’s green has crafted an EP that feels less like a collection of songs and more like an immersive experience. Beautifully written and thoughtfully composed, every track flows [...]

7.0

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: JACK GRISHAM AND THE LIFE UNDONE – JACK GRISHAM AND THE LIFE UNDONE

by Gerrod Harris on July 10, 2026

JACK GRISHAM AND THE LIFE UNDONE JACK GRISHAM AND THE LIFE UNDONE LOST IN BERLIN RECORDS T.S.O.L.’s Jack Grisham has made a triumphant solo return with his new band, Jack Grisham And The Life Undone, with the release of their debut, eponymous [...]

8.0

SPILL ALBUM REVIEW: SWEET – THE ANSWER

by Aaron Badgley on July 10, 2026

SWEET THE ANSWER METALVILLE The Answer was originally released in 1992 under the name Andy Scott’s Sweet rather than just Sweet. It was also originally released with the title A and was originally Sweet’s 10th album. It was released only in [...]